Insights

/

Benefits 101

What is a PBM? Understanding How Pharmacy Benefit Managers Work

Benefits 101
November 19, 2026
What is a PBM? Understanding How Pharmacy Benefit Managers Work
All set! Your report is ready.

Thanks for submitting the form. You can now download your report using the button below.

Download Report
Download Report

Transform health and pharmacy benefits

Talk to Our Team
Talk to Our Team
Listen on:

Listen on

Spotify

Listen on

Apple Podcast

Listen on

Amazon Music

Listen on

Audible

Listen on

iHeart Radio

Episode Guests
No items found.

Prescription drug benefits can be one of the more complicated parts of a health plan to evaluate. There are pricing benchmarks to account for, pharmacy networks to manage, manufacturer rebates to negotiate, and claims rules that all factor into what a plan pays and what members pay at the pharmacy counter. A Pharmacy Benefit Manager (PBM) works across all of these moving parts.

A PBM is a company that manages prescription drug benefits on behalf of health plans, including administering pharmacy claims, negotiating with drug manufacturers and pharmacies, managing formularies and pharmacy networks, and overseeing programs that shape how prescription benefits work.

For plan sponsors, a PBM's business model can say a lot about how their pharmacy benefit is managed. Pricing benchmarks, rebate arrangements, and contract terms all determine how the benefit is structured and where the money goes. Knowing how those pieces fit together can help provide a clearer picture of what their PBM is delivering and where costs are coming from.

‍What Does a Pharmacy Benefit Manager Do?

According to data cited by the U.S Government Accountability Office (GAO), more than 275 million Americans receive prescription drug benefits through PBMs, which coordinate several parts of the prescription drug supply chain that connect health plans, pharmacies, drug manufacturers, and the patients who rely on prescription coverage.  

To see where PBMs fit into the process, it helps to look at the key stakeholders within the benefit ecosystem that PBMs interact with:

  • Health plans and plan sponsors that fund or provide prescription drug benefits are the PBM’s primary clients.
  • Drug manufacturers negotiate with PBMs to set drug prices and negotiate rebates or other payments.
  • Retail, mail-order, and specialty pharmacies that dispense covered medications participate in the PBM’s network of providers.
  • Members who use the pharmacy benefit to access prescribed treatments interact with the PBM in multiple ways.

On a day-to-day basis, PBM responsibilities commonly include:

  • Processing prescription claims and applying plan benefit rules at the point of sale
  • Building and maintaining pharmacy networks, including reimbursement arrangements.
  • Developing formularies that outline which medications are covered and at what tier.
  • Administering clinical programs that support plan sponsors and patients through utilization management, cost containment, patient safety, population health, and high-touch, personalized care.
  • Supporting members through service functions, communications, and digital tools.

A PBM's contract outlines how these services are delivered and how the company is compensated. Even when two plans use the same PBM, their costs and coverage can differ depending on the terms of their agreements, since those terms establish how prescriptions are priced and paid.‍

Why Is PBM Reform in the News?

PBM business practices have drawn increased attention from federal and state policymakers. According to Drug Channels, the three largest PBMs processed approximately 80% of equivalent prescription claims in 2025. With so much of the market concentrated among a few companies, recent federal reforms reflect growing scrutiny of these practices, with new requirements aimed at giving health plans more insight into how PBMs structure their contracts and earn revenue, including how they’re compensated.

What Do Recent PBM Transparency Reforms Include?

Federal efforts to increase transparency in pharmacy benefits gained new momentum with the Consolidated Appropriations Act of 2026, which included bipartisan reforms addressing PBM compensation disclosures. In October 2026, the U.S. Department of Labor finalized a rule addressing PBM compensation disclosure for certain large, self-insured group health plans. With  

The rule requires greater disclosure of PBM and affiliated broker or consultant compensation, manufacturer payments, and certain differences between what plans are charged and what pharmacies receive in addition to establishing fiduciary audit rights.

You can disclose a lot of information and still have a business model that benefits when costs go up.

- Kristin Begley, PharmD, Chief Commercial Officer

Access to disclosures is a starting point, but plan sponsors also need a way to verify how their PBM operates. An auditable workflow makes it possible to follow the money, review the underlying transactions, and compare what the contract says with what happened on actual claims. Access to data is most useful when it can be traced, reconciled, and tested.

How Do PBMs Control Prescription Drug Costs?

PBMs control prescription spending through benefit design, pharmacy network arrangements, and coverage policies that guide which medications members can access and under what conditions. They also negotiate prices with supply chain partners on behalf of health plans, which contribute to setting prescription prices, the plan’s share of the cost, and what members end up paying.

What Is Prior Authorization?

Prior authorization (PA) is a process where approval is required before a plan covers certain medications. A PA review may confirm that a drug is appropriate for the diagnosis, that clinical criteria are met, the medication is safe for the member, or that other treatment options have been considered. Clear criteria and timely decisions are important to prevent unnecessary delays in care.

What Is Step Therapy?

Step therapy asks a member to try a preferred medication before the plan covers a different, often more expensive, treatment. The preferred option may be a generic or another clinically appropriate drug. Plans should have a clear exception process for members whose medical needs call for a different treatment.

How Do Formulary Tiers Work?

A formulary is the list of prescription drugs covered by a plan. Medications are often grouped into tiers, with each tier carrying a different member cost share. Generic drugs may sit on lower-cost tiers, while preferred and nonpreferred brand-name or specialty medications may have higher cost sharing. Manufacturers may make rebate arrangements contingent onto specific formulary tier placement, making it important to review the clinical rationale and financial incentives behind coverage and tiering decisions.

A typical four-tier formulary may look like this:

  • Tier 1: Generic drugs. Typically carry the lowest copays and include medications that are no longer patent protected and are produced by multiple manufacturers. ‍
  • Tier 2: Preferred brand-name drugs. Include brand-name medications selected as preferred options, generally with moderate member cost sharing. ‍
  • Tier 3: Nonpreferred brand-name drugs. Often carry higher copays or coinsurance because lower-cost alternatives may be available. ‍
  • Tier 4: Specialty medications. Include drugs used to treat complex or chronic conditions and often have the highest member cost-sharing.  

Tier structures and cost-sharing requirements vary by plan.

Where a medication falls within a formulary tier structure tells members what their cost-sharing requirements are. PBM pricing arrangements address a different cost: what the plan is charged for covered medications.

How Are Prescription Drug Prices Calculated?

PBM contracts use different benchmarks to calculate the amount a health plan pays for a prescription. Two common approaches are Average Wholesale Price (AWP) and National Average Drug Acquisition Cost (NADAC) pricing.

What are AWP-Based and NADAC-Based Pricing?

Pricing model How it works What plan sponsors should review
AWP-based pricing Uses Average Wholesale Price, a published list-price benchmark, as the starting point for a negotiated discount. The AWP discount, dispensing fees, definitions, and whether the benchmark provides a meaningful comparison.
NADAC-based pricing Uses National Average Drug Acquisition Cost, a public benchmark, as a reference point for ingredient cost, with contract-defined adjustments. How NADAC is applied, what happens when a drug has no published NADAC, and which fees or adjustments are added.

Neither AWP nor NADAC represents the final amount a health plan pays for a prescription on its own. Each benchmark serves as a starting point for the pricing terms outlined in the PBM contract. Discounts, dispensing fees, and other adjustments can drive the final amount the plan pays. Review how each benchmark is applied and what additional charges are included.

How Do PBMs Make Money?

PBMs earn revenue through compensation arrangements outlined in their contracts with health plans. Some traditional arrangements allow PBMs to generate revenue through spread pricing or retained manufacturer rebates, while other arrangements separate PBM compensation from prescription drug costs through defined administrative fees. Revenue can also come from pharmacy ownership. When a PBM owns mail-order or specialty pharmacies, it may earn money from the prescriptions those pharmacies dispense.

What Is Spread Pricing in Pharmacy Benefits?

In its most obvious form, spread pricing occurs when a PBM charges a health plan more for a prescription claim than it reimburses the pharmacy, retaining the difference as revenue. For example, a plan might be charged $100 while the pharmacy receives $80. The $20 difference is the spread.

Identifying spread pricing can be difficult when a contract doesn’t require claim-level reporting of both amounts. When reviewing a PBM proposal, plan sponsors should ask whether spread pricing is used, how pharmacy reimbursement rates are set, and whether the plan can audit the amounts charged and paid.  

Spread pricing can also involve more complex arrangements, including differences in reimbursement across pharmacies or the use of Maximum Allowable Cost (MAC) lists. The contract should explain how pharmacy payments are calculated and how the PBM is compensated.

What is Pass-Through Pricing?

Pass-through pricing separates the PBM’s administrative compensation from prescription drug costs. Rather than retaining a spread between what the health plan pays and what the pharmacy receives, the PBM passes through the pharmacy reimbursement amount and receives an agreed-upon administrative fee.

However, eliminating spread pricing doesn’t address every conflict in a PBM’s business model. When a PBM or its parent company owns dispensing pharmacies, it can have a financial incentive to profit from the medications being dispensed.

As the CEO of a PBM that does not own a pharmacy or otherwise profit from a plan sponsor’s drug spend, I can assure you that it is not necessary for a PBM – or its parent company – to own a specialty pharmacy.

‍
- AJ Loiacono, CEO

Pharmacy ownership can create financial incentives tied to the medications being dispensed. Health plans need visibility into how affiliated pharmacies are reimbursed and the ability to audit those transactions to see where pharmacy dollars go.

How Do PBMs Handle Drug Rebates?

Drug manufacturers may pay rebates to PBMs under agreements that may be based on formulary placement, utilization, or other contract terms. Rebate amounts and conditions vary by drug and agreement. Whether the plan receives those dollars depends on the PBM contract and the way rebate revenue is defined.

Plan sponsors should review how rebates are calculated, when they’re reported, which fees or offsets may be deducted, and whether the contract covers other manufacturer payments in addition to traditional rebates.

What Is Rebate Pass-Through?

Rebate pass-through means the PBM returns the contractually defined rebate amounts to the health plan rather than retaining them as revenue. The agreement should spell out what counts as a rebate, whether administrative charges or other deductions apply, and when funds are credited.  

Clear pass-through terms make it easier to verify how rebate dollars are handled and whether a PBM’s financial incentives align with the plan’s interests. For example, a manufacturer may offer a larger rebate in exchange for a preferred formulary placement, even when a competing medication has a lower list price.

What Questions Should Plan Sponsors Ask When Evaluating a PBM?‍

A PBM proposal can look straightforward until the contract language is examined. These questions can help surface the financial and operational details that shape the relationship.

  1. How are prescription drug prices calculated? Ask which benchmark is used, how discounts and fees are applied, and what happens when a benchmark value is unavailable. ‍
  2. Does the contract allow the PBM to earn a spread? Confirm how pharmacy reimbursement is reported whether the plan can compare the amount charged with the amount paid to the pharmacy, and whether other sources of spread or arbitrage are disclosed. ‍
  3. How are manufacturer rebates and other payments handled? Request clear definitions, reporting timelines, and confirmation of what’s passed through. ‍
  4. Who owns the claims data, and what can the plan audit? Look for timely access to claim-level information, payment records, and supporting documentation
  5. ‍How are clinical programs and formularies evaluated? Ask how utilization controls are designed, monitored, and adjusted when they create barriers to appropriate treatment.

A PBM proposal should hold up under scrutiny, and the contract must clearly define how pricing is calculated, how payments are handled, and what information the plan can access. With those details in hand, plan sponsors have a better foundation for comparing PBMs and evaluating if the arrangement aligns with their priorities.

CLIENT SPOTLIGHT

Subaru of Indiana Automotive

For Julia Bryan, Benefits and Compensation Manager at Subaru of Indiana Automotive, greater PBM transparency changed how her team evaluated benefit costs. Having clearer information made it easier to see what the plan was paying and why, replacing assumptions with data they could use to have greater control over their pharmacy benefit.

“Employers sometimes assume transparency means bare bones, but in reality, it means you finally see what you’re paying for and why. So, it’s really a shift from guessing to knowing.”

Julia Bryan
Julia Bryan, SHRM-SCP Benefits and Compensation Manager Subaru of Indiana Automotive

How Does Judi Rx™ Approach Pharmacy Benefit Management Differently?

Judi Rx, the pharmacy benefit management division of Judi Health™, grew out of a straightforward conviction: prescription benefits should operate with greater transparency, and patients should never be confused or taken advantage of when accessing care.

Our founding mission was to change how drugs are priced and patients are cared for. For Judi Rx, that means challenging the traditional PBM model, especially the financial arrangements that can obscure how prescription costs are determined and where money goes. We put that belief into practice by passing through 100% of manufacturer rebates and avoiding spread pricing and retained rebate dollars.

Take a Closer Look at Your Pharmacy Benefit

Your PBM contract should make it clear how prescription prices are set, where rebate dollars go, and how your PBM is compensated. If those details are difficult to find, a closer review can help identify gaps in pricing transparency and reporting.

Learn how Judi Rx is rethinking pharmacy benefit management and putting members, plan sponsors, and greater accountability at the center of the benefit.  

Frequently Asked Questions About Pharmacy Benefit Managers

What is the difference between a PBM and pharmacy benefit administration? ‍

A PBM manages prescription drug benefits, including claims processing, formulary administration, pharmacy network arrangements, and related clinical programs. Pharmacy benefit administration generally refers to the operational work involved in running those benefits. The specific services and financial arrangements depend on the contract. ‍

How do PBMs make money? ‍

PBM compensation varies by business model and contract. Revenue may include administrative fees, spread pricing, retained manufacturer rebates, or other payments. Plan sponsors should request a complete accounting of compensation and review how each payment is treated in the agreement.

‍What is NADAC pricing? ‍

NADAC, or National Average Drug Acquisition Cost, is a CMS-published benchmark based on invoice prices reported by retail community pharmacies. It provides a public reference point for ingredient cost, although it may not match the exact acquisition cost for every pharmacy or every drug.

‍Do plan sponsors always receive drug rebates? ‍

No. Whether rebate dollars are returned to a plan depends on the contract. Some agreements allow the PBM to retain some or all rebate amounts, while pass-through arrangements return the contractually defined rebate dollars to the plan. Even under pass-through arrangements, a PBM can exclude certain manufacturer revenue streams from the definition of “rebates” that are to be passed-through, effectively allowing the PBM to retain dollars that would otherwise be considered a rebate.

‍What is the difference between spread pricing and pass-through pricing? ‍

With spread pricing, a PBM may charge the plan more than it reimburses the pharmacy and retain the difference. In a pass-through model, pharmacy reimbursement and plan charges are disclosed separately, with the PBM compensated through the fees defined in the contract.

‍Why can pharmacy costs rise after a PBM contract is renegotiated? ‍

A lower discount or revised fee does not necessarily mean lower total costs. Drug mix, utilization, list-price changes, formulary placement, pharmacy reimbursement, rebates, and contract definitions can all affect plan and patient costs. Reviewing claim-level data alongside the full contract can help explain the change.

SHARE

Copied!

It's time to build your benefits, your way.

Get in touch to learn about our health benefit administration and transparent pharmacy benefit management solutions.

Talk to Our Experts
Talk to Our Experts